What is in use here is amazingly out of date, and there is no way I can give you a concrete answer, but I might have a suggestion or two.
For the encryption algorithm you have selected DES. Even back in the 6.x series, DES was already obsolete, and was replaced by 3DES. Since there is no DES built into the 6.5.2 version of PGP, which is what it looks like they are trying to decrypt with, the session key is invalid (pgp error -11476), causing it to fail and terminate with a decryption error (exit code 32).
Try it again using 3DES, or one of the other ciphers available for PGP version 6.5.2 (other choices: CAST5 or IDEA). Let me know if that works.