Messaging Gateway

 View Only
  • 1.  Trend Micro ScanMail Exchange Suite Vs Brightmail Antispam

    Posted May 17, 2009 02:23 PM
    hi,
    can any body shed some lights or compare for us between Symantec brightmail antispam and Trend Micro ScanMail Exchange Suite .
    currently I have brightmail 6.2 sitting on a dedicated WIN2K3 server (smtp gateway) and I have Scna Mail for Exchange (version 7) installed on my Exchange 2003 server,
    scan mail was previously focused on virus detection but now they do include antspam.
    my question is can I safely ditch the brightmail and depend only on scanmail (to reduce over head and hardware resources) ?
    thx


  • 2.  RE: Trend Micro ScanMail Exchange Suite Vs Brightmail Antispam

    Posted May 19, 2009 02:01 PM
    Hello,
    I think you miss one critical decision criteria here, which is the accuracy of the spam filtering and the amount of possible false-positives. If you look to independent analysts report such as Gartner Magic Quadrant, Radicati Market Quadrant or Forrester Wave, Symantec Messaging Security products are always up in the leading quadrant, whilst Trend Micro isn't. So why would you like to switch off an antispam engine, that gives you much higher accuracy and lower amount of false positives just to overcome overhead and hardware resources?
    You might want to consider the migration to Symantec Brightmail Gateway 8.0, which gives you inbound and outbound messaging security for email and IM, with effective and accurate antispam and antivirus protection, advanced content filtering, and data loss prevention technology. So spam mails won't even hit your Exchange environment and can be quarantined separately for further inspections by the user or the admin if you need to (in fact, many customers switch this quarantine off after a while because they realise the accuracy of the antispam filtering and they realise, that the mail users are not looking into the quarantine anymore to check for possible missed items).
    So on the Exchange Server itself, you can run antivirus/antispyware engine, i.e. Symantec Mail Security for Exchange. Brightmail Gateway 8.0 and Mail Security for Exchange is part of Symantec Multi-tier Protection bundle and it is available at a very attractive crossgrade price from your current Brightmail 6.2 version. 
    Running the antispam engine on the Exchange Server itself is not a recommended solution, because it doesn't keep the spam and malicious code overhead away from the Exchange environment. Doing it on the gateway level is a better approach.


  • 3.  RE: Trend Micro ScanMail Exchange Suite Vs Brightmail Antispam

    Posted May 19, 2009 02:30 PM
    @Guido: I'd like to see the links to the reports you mentioned. Thanks.


  • 4.  RE: Trend Micro ScanMail Exchange Suite Vs Brightmail Antispam

    Posted May 19, 2009 02:35 PM
    Not sure if this helps. My company used to use Trend Micro. (it was an older version) and I just implemented Brightmail gateway 8.0.1-7. We absolutely love it. The dashboard is great for presentations ( higher-ups always like graphs ). We get about 500,000 e-mails a day, and about 95.7% are bad reputation 3.9% are spam .3% virus and compliance. The spam Quarantine box is very fast to search ( our old product would take about 10 mins to search).
    We implemented 2 scanners and 1 control center. Please feel free to ask questions. I am in no way affiliated with Symantec.

    Mike


  • 5.  RE: Trend Micro ScanMail Exchange Suite Vs Brightmail Antispam

    Posted May 19, 2009 02:47 PM
    The Forrester Wave and Gartner Magic Quadrant reports can be found on http://www.symantec.com/about/industryanalysts/analystreports.jsp#email. We currently don't have publication right for the Radicati Market Quadrant report, but you will find some more details on http://www.radicati.com.


  • 6.  RE: Trend Micro ScanMail Exchange Suite Vs Brightmail Antispam
    Best Answer

    Posted May 24, 2009 07:20 PM
    I would suggest not. I have scanmail installed as you do, but also have Tremd IMSS on my Gateway for spam. Once you move brightmail off your Gateway, the spam is going to hit your Exchange Server directly. And depending on how much you get -- could cause your Exchange Server to drop-off considerably in performance.